Beach Vacations

The 12 secret Caribbean islands you may not have heard of, yet

Last updated 20th April 2025

It’s no secret that the Caribbean is chock full of beautiful destinations, and some are still under-the-radar, take a look at 12 secret Caribbean islands Bridgette Langdon found.

guadeloupe-secret-caribbean-island

Guadeloupe: the secret Caribbean island kids will love

This French island group in the Caribbean has long stretches of beach and old sugarcane fields. Part of the charm of Guadeloupe is that it remains a truly undiscovered secret Caribbean island. But what does exist in terms of restaurants and hotels is less polished than on many islands — and far more authentic.

dominica-secret-caribbean-island

Dominica: discover this secret for mountains and hot springs

Known as the “nature island”, Dominica is a mountainous secret Caribbean island with natural hot springs and tropical rainforests. Morne Trois Pitons National Park is home to the volcanically heated, steam-covered Boiling Lake.

Bonaire-secret-caribbean-island

Bonaire: the Caribbean’s top shore diving destination

Bonaire isn’t just a secret Caribbean island, it’s a municipality of the Netherlands, and lies off the coast of Venezuela in the southern Caribbean — near Aruba and Curaçao. Along with activities such as kite surfing, windsurfing and snorkeling, Bonaire is known as one of the top destinations in the world for sustainable tourism. It has long been recognized as the preeminent Shore Diving Destination in the Caribbean/Atlantic in Scuba Diving Magazine’s Annual Readers’ Choice Awards, and it was also voted number one for Macro Diving and Beginner Diving.

the-abacos-secret-caribbean-islands

The Abacos: the ones to visit for underwater caves

The Abaco Islands are a group of islands and barrier cays in the northern Bahamas. Known for boating and diving, visitors flock to Pelican Cays Land and Sea Park, boasting underwater caves and colorful coral reefs. Farther north, turtles, eagle rays and sharks inhabit Walker’s Cay National Park.
providencia-secret-caribbean-island

Providencía: the secret with many ecosystems

Isla de Providencía is a Colombian-Caribbean island situated in the Caribbean Sea, about 140 miles off the coast of Nicaragua. The island hosts numerous ecosystems including mangroves, coral reefs, seagrass, dry forest and mountainous terrain.

montserrat-volcanic-caribbean-islands

Montserrat: the peaceful home to an active volcano

Many might be deterred from visiting Montserrat as the least-visited island in the Caribbean, home to an active volcano and with limited transportation options. But hosting so few tourists means that this is an island where you can savor the Caribbean beauty in peace and tranquillity.

harbour-mustique

Mustique: the secret Caribbean island steeped in mystery

Mustique, a private island steeped in history and surrounded by intrigue, lies in the stream of islands of St. Vincent and the Grenadines — just a hundred miles west of Barbados. It’s known for its free-spirited vibe, unmanicured, white sand beaches and its native seabirds. In town you’ll find fresh fruit stalls and small shops.

mountain-town-saba

Saba: ‘unspoiled queen of the Caribbean’

Saba, a 12-minute flight from neighboring St. Marteen, is known as the “Unspoiled Queen of the Caribbean”. You’ll find no franchises in this secret Caribbean island; Rather, eclectic bars and small restaurants will infuse your nightlife after hiking a mountain rainforest trail, dived at an acclaimed site or just lounged by a pool.

beach-british-virgin-islands

Guana Island: one of the many British Virgin Islands

Guana Island is one of the many British Virgin Islands. What sets it apart is that it’s one of the few remaining privately owned islands in the Caribbean. Guana has seven white powder sand beaches and boasts a lush tropical forest and mountains. The island is mostly natural preserve and has a small resort.

pier-isla-juventad

Isla de la Juventud: the Caribbean island for pirate secrets

Although the second largest island making up Cuba, La Isla de la Juventud is a little-visited corner of the country. For the lucky ones who do visit, it’s great for diving and rich in beauty and pirate tales.

sailing-caribbean-islands

Culebra: the secret Caribbean island for wildlife lovers

Culebra is one of the small Caribbean islands and surrounding group of cays off the east coast of Puerto Rico. Flamenco Beach is a long crescent of white sand and turquoise water, while Tamarindo Beach boasts crystal clear waters teeming with marine life. The island’s stunning beaches and reefs are protected as part of a U.S. National Wildlife Refuge.

st-eustatius-coastline

St. Eustatius: the island for shipwrecks and serenity

The secret Caribbean island of St. Eustatius (or “Statia”) is known for excellent diving, hiking and serenity. Quill National Park has hiking trails along the ocean and around the island’s volcano. The natural landscape features a rainforest and many species of orchid. Surrounding the island are narrow beaches of volcanic sand, while St. Eustatius National Marine Park’s offshore dive sites include coral reefs shipwrecks.